Knutsford Council Opposes Six-Month Church Hill Closure Plan

Town councillors express 'flabbergasted' reaction to Cheshire East Council's proposal to shut a key route for five months annually.

Generic image of a historic cobbled street in the North West of England.
AI

Generic image of a historic cobbled street in the North West of England.

Knutsford Town Council is urging Cheshire East Council to abandon controversial proposals that would see Church Hill closed for six months of the year.

The proposal by Cheshire East Council involves closing the historic cobbled street from December to April under a planned “experimental” traffic regulation order. This measure is a response to previous cold weather incidents where vehicles have reportedly failed to stop at the bottom of the hill, occasionally colliding with the building opposite.
While the Town Council acknowledges the need for temporary closures during prolonged icy or snowy conditions, councillors are reportedly "flabbergasted" by the plan to shut the street for five months annually. The proposal includes installing a physical barrier near Jessica Stone Salons, preventing access to the remainder of the street. Vehicles, including refuse trucks, delivery vans, and funeral hearses from St John’s Church, would be required to turn around and exit back onto Toft Road.
Town Mayor and Cheshire East Councillor Peter Coan stated, "I consider it unacceptable to close a well used route in weather that makes it safe to use. There are bespoke ways to maintain pedestrian safety in icy and snowy conditions that should be implemented."
Cllr April Johnson, Chair of the Knutsford Town Council Town Centre Committee and councillor for Bexton and Town Centre ward, added, "This road is an important part of our town’s infrastructure, serving residents, local businesses and visitors. Its closure risks creating unnecessary disruption for access to our main car park, increasing traffic on King Edward Road and Adams Hill and negatively affecting the daily lives of those who live and work in the town."
The proposal, initially mooted in 2023, has faced objections from the Town Council. Cheshire East Council data suggests 1,000 vehicles a day would be displaced onto Toft Road and Adams Hill, which they consider negligible. However, the Town Council highlights Church Hill's value as a local route that eases pressure on congested roads and provides easy access to the town’s main car park.
Concerns have also been raised about the impact on high street businesses, particularly during a challenging economic period. The Town Council has challenged the estimated cost of the proposal, around £8,500, compared to temporary closures costing approximately £130 each.
An experimental traffic regulation order would typically last 18 months, with a formal review after six months. However, the Town Council was informed by Cheshire East Highways officers that the borough council is determined to proceed, viewing the full closure as the only safe solution. The Town Council has urged for alternative solutions, such as improved surfacing, gritting, and continuing current temporary closures, to be explored.
A petition against the closure, launched by local businesses, has already garnered over 600 signatures. Cllr Johnson emphasised, "We believe the community deserves to have its voice heard and its concerns taken seriously. We oppose Cheshire East Council closing our local roads without valid justification."
The Town Council is writing to Cheshire East Council Highways Portfolio Holder Cllr Mark Goldsmith and Interim Executive Director of Place Richard Kenny seeking their intervention. Residents concerned about the closure are encouraged to sign the petition and contact Cheshire East Council.
Based on information from the official source: Knutsford Town Council (23/10/2026)